A wonderful transformation of the Ugly Duckling

De humani corporis fabrica libri septem (1555) by Andreas Vesalius, photo by Christie's

The story of how the second edition of the book De humani corporis fabrica libri septem, by Flemish Andreas Vesalius (1514–1564), desecrated by numerous marginal notes, became one of the most outstanding examples of scientific printing that has come down to us has shocked the world of medical history and bibliography. This book, first published in 1543, then revolutionised anatomy, laying the foundations and standards for anatomical research for the next several hundred years. In a luxurious folio-sized book, the author not only provided a detailed description of the structure of the human body, illustrated with magnificent woodcuts of Musclemen – dissected corpses in elaborate poses, with layers of muscles gradually removed, revealing the depths of the inner world of the human body, but also commented on about 200 mistakes and misconceptions of the infallible authority, Claudius Galenus, questioning more than a thousand years of anatomical beliefs. It is no wonder that the young genius (Andreas Vesalius was only 29 years old when by publishing his Opus magnum) faced not just significant opposition, but fierce hatred, a real mass shitstorm for questioning established views, rocking the comfortable chairs of professorial chairs.

The wooden statue of Claudius Galenus reading his anatomy book. Teatro Anatomico, Palazzo dell’Archiginnasio, University Bologna, Italy

 

In 1555, the scientist published a second edition, expanded and revised. In total, about 150 of its copies have survived to this day, and they are not only kept in museums around the world, but also periodically come up at auctions. So, in 2007, one such copy with the description 'Mod. vellum. - Lacking the pp. 669-672 and the whole index … lightly soiled, here and there contemp. marginalia and underlinings' was put up for auction by the respectable German auction house Keterrer and sold for €13,200 to Gerard Vogrincic, a retired Canadian doctor and avid collector. Antiquarians and book collectors usually avoid books with annotations, considering them desecrated, less valuable, but the price was comparatively not so high (the same auction house a year later sold a similar copy of the second edition of 'In general very fine copy' for 30 thousand euros). 

 

Andreas Vesalius, the only portrait approved by the author. Credit: Christie's

 

Dr. Gerard Vogrincic, the discoverer of the book, drew attention to their strange feature of the 'marginalia' – the notes were not so much scattered comments and thoughts of the reader as an attempt to correct, improve the existing version of the text, and rewrite it. Who could have written these uncommon notes? Could it be possible that this is Andreas Vesalius's personal copy, filled with his extensive notes and additions intended for the never-published third edition? 

Enlightened by the insight, he began to look for ways to test it. However, much fewer handwritten samples of the brilliant scientist have survived to this day than copies of his printed works – less than a ten of his letters have survived. Dr. Vogrincic managed to get copies of two of them, and what was his delight when the handwriting of the notes coincided with the samples of the anatomist’s confirmed autographs! These actually turned out to be Vesalius' own notes, and instead of a soiled second edition, the book instantly turned into one of the most important medical works in the entire history of mankind! This discovery allows to look into the mind of one of the most important physicians in history, and understand what other changes were planned to be made in the future third edition.

Unsurprisingly, when auctioned by Christie's auction in January 2024, the book broke numerous records with a selling price of $2.228 million, making it one of the ten most expensive scientific titles ever sold. Among other things, it exceeded the $1,652,500 paid at Christie's auction in 1998 for the first edition, personally dedicated by Vesalius to the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V – this copy of 1543 is easy to distinguish from others as the only known color (hand-painted) edition.

 

Hand-colored woodcut Andreas Vesalius (1514-1564) from the 'De humani corporis fabrica libri septem'. Dedication copy presented by Vesalius to Charles V (1500-1558), Holy Roman Emperor, 1543. Source: commons.wikimedia.org. Courtesy of an Anonymous Private Collector; photo courtesy of Christie's, New York

  

Christie's revealed that the Department of Culture, Flemish Community, acquired Andreas Vesalius' personally annotated edition of 'De humani corporis fabrica', in partnership with KU Leuven. This significant piece will be exhibited at KU Leuven, the most ancient university in the Low Countries. Born in Brussels in 1514 as Andries van Wesel, the genial anatomist latinized his name as Andreas Vesalius. Initially attending the University of Leuven, the return of Vesalius' landmark publication to this institution marks a symbolic homecoming.

 

The second edition of the book De humani corporis fabrica libri septem (1555), by Flemish Andreas Vesalius. Credit: Christie's

 

Additional reading:

"Bookfind of the century" sells for $2.23 million

Lot description by Ketterer

Lot Assay by Christie's

 

More info

warning-red Found mistake? Select text and press Ctrl+Enter (for Mac: Cmd+Enter)

See also

Poor condition rating C3 may have noticeable damage or significant signs of wear, major scratches, dents, or even parts that are broken or missing. Items may require restoration
Conditions ratings

In the world of collecting antiques of medical instruments are often graded based on their condition. The ratings like C1, C2, and C3 are used to indicate the state of preservation and the amount of wear or damage an item has sustained over time. C1 – excellent condition, with minimal signs of wear or use and retains most of its original features and functionality. C2 – good condition but may show more evident signs of wear or aging. C3 – fair or poor condition with noticeable damage or significant signs of wear.

Brambilla, Giovanni Alessandro. Instrumentarium chirurgicum militare Austriacum, Vienna, 1782.
Dating antique catalogs of medical instruments

Establishing the publication date of a medical trade catalogs is not always trivial. Many medical instrument manufacturers did without catalogs for many years – there was simply no need for them. Then, when the first trade catalogs of medical and surgical instruments appeared, they often omitted the date of their publications. There are several indications that can be used to determine the approximate year of publication of catalogs, which are discussed in this article.

Wellcome Catalog of Printed Books
Important Catalogs of Historical Medical Books

To find the right path in the ocean of historical books, we can turn to some catalogs of the most important examples of historical literature in medicine. The most respected for their thoroughness and historical value are seminal resources for researchers looking for rare and important medical books of the past. References to their records are often found in the reference departments of university libraries and specialized institutions and are often cited by booksellers of scientific and antiquarian books: Wellcome Historical Medical Library Catalogue; Garrison-Morton's Medical Bibliography; Hirsch's Biographisches Lexikon der hervorragenden Ärzte; Osler's Bibliotheca Osleriana; The Bibliotheca Walleriana; The Harvey Cushing Catalogue; Heirs of Hippocrates; Catalogue of the History of Medicine Collection in the National Library of Medicine.